Rahm Emanuel’s Political Pirouettes

God help me, but I had to laugh when I heard the news that Barack Obama had named Rahm Emanuel as White House chief of staff. What else could I do? Without even so much as a symbolic gesture in support of reform, the great agent of “change” immediately selected as his chief political enforcer a figure who epitomizes the Washington consensus of the past two decades — pro-“free trade,” pro-Iraq invasion/occupation and, perhaps most importantly, pro-pork barrel.
Which isn’t to say that Emanuel does not possess great talents essential to the success of an Obama administration. It just depends on how you define success. If Emanuel’s legendary aggressiveness were put to work in the service of “good government,” he might, indeed, do wonderful things. But I somehow doubt that’s what Obama has in mind for his friend from Chicago as he embarks on his 2012 re-election campaign.
Like Obama, Rahm Emanuel was launched in politics by the Daley machine, but he really made his name in the Clinton administration as one of three principal White House lobbyists for the North American Free Trade Agreement, in 1993. Working alongside Mayor Richard M. Daley’s brother, William, and then-U.S. Trade Representative Mickey Kantor, Emanuel developed a reputation for having “a personality that killed plants on contact,” in the words of Margarita Roque, a former House staffer.
I can confirm Roque’s assessment, since in my own interviews with Emanuel, he outdid himself in ferocious candor. Asked to describe the effectiveness and reliability of his pro-NAFTA allies at the Business Roundtable, Emanuel was effusive in his praise of Allied Signal Chairman Larry Bossidy and a few others at Boeing and IBM. But as for “the rest of business — not worth a bucket of warm spit.”
Ordinarily, I might appreciate such a remark, but Emanuel was only expressing a certain type of politician’s contempt for anyone who is not a politician or their surrogate — for people insufficiently ruthless to “get the job done,” as Obama puts it. That Emanuel dared to say this during his brief tenure as an investment banker only accentuates his sense of superiority over the mere mortals who live outside the charmed triangle of Capitol Hill/K Street/Democratic Party power.
To be sure, a President Obama needs a henchman — but it’s important to know to what end. Like H.R. “Bob” Haldeman, Richard Nixon’s chief of staff, Emanuel will no doubt involve himself in many pressing matters of state, from maintaining the status quo in the Mideast to deciding which campaign contributor gets to be ambassador to Sri Lanka.
But in RahmObama world, it’s the political tasks that always come first, foremost among them rewarding your friends and punishing your enemies. At the top of a very urgent list of priorities will be thanking Mayor Daley for his early endorsement of Obama during the primaries — preferably with a goody guaranteed to create a lot of patronage jobs, such as bringing the 2016 Olympic games to the Windy City.
As a congressman and chairman of the House Democratic Caucus, Emanuel has reached deep into the pork barrel, and last year he defended an “earmark” that permitted the rebuilding of a bridge in his district “that not only was rated as deficient but also was identified by the Department of Homeland Security as a major evacuation route in case of a terrorist attack on Chicago.” Posing a largely rhetorical question, Emanuel wrote: “Does that make me an ‘earmark thug’ or a congressman who took care of a critical need in his district?”
It’s unclear what would motivate al-Qaida to target Illinois’s 5th Congressional District — why bother hitting Wrigley Field and the Cubs when they’re already doomed? — but what is clear is that Emanuel knows how to game the system. What’s more, like his tutor, Mayor Daley, he understands the political value of “terrorism” to accomplish important civic improvements. In 2003, Daley unilaterally tore up the runway of Chicago’s lakefront airport, Meigs Field, in the middle of the night, so he could reclaim the land for a park. As justification, the mayor cited the threat of terrorist attack (from the air), even though neither Secretary of Homeland Security Tom Ridge or his agency were ever consulted and Ridge declared himself “disappointed” by the Meigs shutdown.
With all this, I can’t deny feeling a kind of admiration for Emanuel. All through the 2008 campaign, he performed a balancing act — never publicly supporting Obama until Hillary Clinton dropped out — worthy of a professional ballet dancer. In fact, Emanuel was a ballet student when he was growing up in suburban Chicago, good enough to be offered a scholarship by the Joffrey Ballet. As it happens, I spent a lot of time as a kid at the studio where he trained, the Evanston School of Ballet, watching my sister, a future professional, take class.
It would be easy to suggest that Emanuel’s tough-guy behavior is a case of overcompensation for having spent so much of his young life in what some might view as a “feminine” milieu. I don’t see it that way, even though I resisted occasional recruiting attempts by the school’s co-founder, Phyllis Wills, for the usual “that’s too sissy” reason.
Anybody familiar with the ballet world knows that the small number of dancers who make a paying career of it are the equivalent of professional athletes — every bit as accomplished as the best football, basketball and track stars — and not sissies at all. In ballet, the self-discipline and physical training required to “get the job done” are not for weaklings.
Thus, Obama may well have done himself a favor by picking a former ballet man to run the White House.
We can only hope that if he does his grands battements in the Oval Office, he doesn’t accidentally kick over the red phone and start a war.
ORIGINALLY POST VIA THE PROVIDENCE JOURNAL
- FILED UNDER: Guest Blogger, Obama, President-elect, Rahm Emanuel, Rahmbo
- November 20, 2008








Hmmm... EXCELLENT!
Obama must be on the right path... He's being mercilessly attacked from both sides.
- Email this page
By A GNovember 20, 2008 - 9:19amMeet the new boss, same as the old boss.
look who got fooled again. pete townsend.
- Email this page
By momofukuNovember 20, 2008 - 9:49amHuh?
Pete Townshend got fooled again? By whom?
What in the hells are you on about?
If all else fails, immortality can always be assured by spectacular error. ~~~John Kenneth Galbraith
- Email this page
By nonexistent manNovember 20, 2008 - 9:55amUhhh...
WANNA BET?
ALL IN, PUNK.
- Email this page
By A GNovember 20, 2008 - 10:53amDifference between the new and old bosses
Old Boss:
Can barely speak English
New Boss:
Delivers uplifting speeches in wonderful prose
Old Boss:
Gropes female foreign heads of state
New Boss:
Appoints his chief female competitor SecState
Old Boss:
Drove three companies into the ground before being elected governor based solely on his last name
New Boss:
President of the Harvard Law Review; successful law practice; taught constitutional law; elected to state and US senates
Old Boss:
Shredded the US Constitution
New Boss:
Taught Constitutional law; much more likely to follow constitutional dictates
- Email this page
By blogbobNovember 23, 2008 - 2:08amI have my concerns about this appointment
as well, especially when you go back to the Obama comment about clinging to guns and religion. The part of that comment that the corporate media always cut off was Obama's comment about how trade agreements contributed to the anger.
I don't know what Obama would expect since 6 million Americans have lost their living wage manufacturing jobs in exchange for Walmart specials thanks to the likes of dickheads like Emanuel. Not being able to afford healthcare, putting your kids through college, paying your mortgage, paying your car payment and in general recieving the respect that fellow citizens deserve from their government tends to piss people off and ruin economies.
- Email this page
By AntillectualNovember 21, 2008 - 4:51amEmanuel probably has skills
Emanuel probably has skills Obama would like to tap. You make it sound like Emanuel is in charge of what happens. A good president uses people, and he doesn't let them use him. I think Emanuel will follow Obama's agenda, not vice-versa...and that goes for all of Obama's appointees. It's a good way to keep them under control.
- Email this page
By MichtouNovember 21, 2008 - 8:38pmExcellent Point, Michtou...
... Obama will be a stark contrast to the bumbling buffoon Bush, who let Cheney, Rummy and PNAC lead him around by a ring in his nose.
- Email this page
By othelloNovember 22, 2008 - 5:32pmDon't forget
Fredo Gonzales
- Email this page
By blogbobNovember 23, 2008 - 2:09amGood Call, Bob...
... unfortunately, I don't think we will be able to forget about that bastard for a long, long time. The scars PNAC & BushCo left on this country will take a long time to heal, if ever.
- Email this page
By othelloNovember 23, 2008 - 9:00amThe best revenge!
SUCCESS!! SUCCESS!!! SUCCESS!! YES WE CAN!!
- Email this page
By Viv RichardsNovember 24, 2008 - 12:08pmBut the appointment of people like Emmanuel
makes me wonder exactly what Obama's agenda is.
- Email this page
By thaelmann37November 23, 2008 - 9:47amAgenda
A Brave New World. Yes we can! Past does not have to be prologue.
- Email this page
By Viv RichardsNovember 24, 2008 - 12:04pm